
Some Miyazaki fans seem to be, at least mildly, disappointed in Ponyo in comparison to the master's other animated films. I can't understand almost any of their arguments, and I can't help but wonder if some are registering disagreement less with the film itself than with the Disney Corporation's decision to release the film only in a dubbed version, in contrast to their making Howl's Moving Castle available to theatres both an English-dubbed and a Japanese-language version with English subtitles. Sprited Away, too, was sent on the festival circuit in a Japanese version before its theatrical release with American voice artists providing the soundtrack.
I've watched both versions of Ponyo. First I saw a 35mm print of the Disney-dubbed version; though I was mildly bothered by Liam Neeson's distinctive tones, and Cate Blanchett's essential reprisal of her Galadriel role, their Ponyo characters are relatively minor and I was so overwhelmed by Miyazaki's fluid animation and florid imagination that they couldn't mar the experience in any meaningful way. The other voice actors submerged their star personae and were unrecognizable to me until the end credits. In sum it was a terrific dub job; nothing like the distracting celebrity voice-fest of the Miramax Princess Mononke dub. Watching a friend's Japanese Ponyo DVD import with English subtitles shortly afterward was nearly as wonderful, but I'm glad it was not my first experience with the film. In fact the dub translation was slightly superior in a few instances, as I confirmed with a native Japanese speaker. The only major improvement was the end-title song, which Disney turned from a sweet farewell to the film into a groan-worthy techno remix involving its stable of pop singers.

Other midnight movies coming to Landmark theatres this season include This is Spinal Tap, the Wiz (featuring Michael Jackson as the scarecrow, of course) the original release cut of Donnie Darko, the Graduate, the Shining, and more. Check the Landmark After Dark website. And though the Bridge will no longer be the site for full summer seasons of Peaches Christ's Midnight Mass series, the horror hostess will present a one-off screening of the Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 there on October 24th.
Meanwhile, the Red Vic on Haight Street has a midnight hit on its hands as well these days. The Room, Tommy Wiseau's enigmatically awful, but clearly rather expensive passion project, has been packing in viewers and solidifying screen-talkback rituals the last Saturday of every month all summer. The tradition, as revealed in the latest Red Vic calendar, is planned to continue this fall with shows on September 26th and October 31st (come in costume as one of the characters for additional fun.)

PONYO, PONYO, PONYO . . .!!!
ReplyDeleteHam-muuuuuuuu!!!!!
I'm a vegetarian but I approve of animated characters eating ham.
ReplyDeletePonyo, Sousuke, SUKI------!!!!!
ReplyDeleteI love Ponyo . It's a great movie and no wonder the theme song of this movie (Po~~nyo po~~nyo ponyo sakananoko!) was all over Japan when this movie was out.
I understand that some people (old Hayao fans) were disappointed in this one because it doesn't seem to have "depth" and "complicated-ness"( did I just made new word?) like his other films.
Hayao's movie is basically for kids. Like "Totoro", "Kiki's delivery serves"(awesome!),,,,but I've been feeling that his stuff went too complicated like Hawl's. So I think this Ponyo, Hayao tried to come back to his old style which I LOVE! Because it's easy to make "complicated-good" than "Simple-good", and I love this "simple-good" movie!!
I agree with Seikov, just because it's geared more towards kids this time around doesn't mean it's any lesser of a Hayao film. Why must the 'great' animated films appeal to both kids and adults to be esteemed? Appealing to just kids is as valid.
ReplyDeleteSeiko, Adam, thanks for your comments! I agree that Ponyo is trying more to be a high-quality entertainment for very young movie-watchers than for all movie-watchers. I wouldn't mind reviews of the film that acknowledge this while expressing that the reviewer didn't personally connect with the film in ways they had with others. Unfortunately, what I've seen more of are claims that Miyazaki is repeating himself, or that he's lost his touch. I wish some of the authors of these pieces could somehow "unsee" My Neighbor Totoro and Spirited Away, or at least come to Ponyo as if they were experiencing Miyazaki for the first time. I think they'd realize it's as beautifully realized and wildly creative as those films, or nearly so at any rate.
ReplyDeleteI think it indeed may be more difficult to make a great "simple" film than a great "complicated" film.
The only critique of Ponyo that has given me serious food for thought (though on first blush I'm not convinced) is this one. I wonder what you think of that analysis?
AAA
Sem dobil užitek od, rezultat sem našel samo tisto, kar sem uporabil, da se ob iskanju. Končali ste moj štiridnevni dolg lov! Bog vas blagoslovi človek. Imejte lep dan. Bye
ReplyDelete